Skip to main content

Story behind the Story

This is a follow-up on an earlier post about Readers Digest.  One of the articles in the July issue was called The Story Behind the Story (this is a link to the online article).  I have thought about this article often since reading it last month.  There are several things that I appreciate and value about the article.

First, many media sources have taken an aggressive stance to defend their news-worthiness.  There are comments like 'we are professionals', 'we don't push opinions', 'we have fact finders', etc.  Instead of listening to concerns that people have, their tone and approach is to attack people for having those concerns.  The simple fact is that more and more people are questioning their news sources and thus feeds the saying 'perception is reality'.

Instead of attacking, Readers Digest decided to dive into their process and what they do to present all sides of an article or news story.  They break it down into four sections - laying the groundwork, getting the goods, asking the experts, and checking and balancing.  The tone of the writing is very neutral and factual - not defensive and definitely not attacking.

Second, my humble opinion is that it is very fair to question the bias of the media.  It does seem that the majority of media mistakes are on just one side of the political spectrum (just compare how many times that media was wrong about Joe Biden versus Donald Trump*).  Further, nothing has changed by those that pushed wrong stories.  Dan Rather was fired from CBS for the misreports about President Bush.  Nobody has loss their jobs or been demoted based on the numerous and many false reports about President Trump.  

What is more troubling is that we are not seeing any changes in the processes and procedures that are followed.  Or maybe they are happening without informing the public.  If so, this is a missed opportunity to be transparent and start to rebuild trust.

Finally, Readers Digest presents itself as just a compilation of articles and not a stand-alone news source.  It is worth noting that many publications and media sources have blurred the lines between news and opinions.  MSNBC and Fox News has news shows in the earlier parts of the evening and then starts their editorial content in the later parts of the evening.  Rachel Maddow and Sean Hannity are presenting opinions, not news.  We as consumers and media companies should stop blurring the lines.  Opinions are important and should be shared, but not just under the banner of news.

I submit that I may be wrong on much or all of the above,   These are, after all, just my opinions.

* The generally accepted misreports about Joe Biden were about his mental capacity, which that reporting only benefited the former President. 


 





Comments

Popular posts from this blog

For Sale: A Wonderful Memory from Childhood

Sorry for the rather large gap in posting.  I recently started a new career opportunity, and it has been a wonderful experience to start.  But also, hard since it has been over 20 years since I last started something new. *** My hometown amusement park is now up for sale .   Even though I do not live in Amarillo anymore, I am somewhat saddened thinking about the possibility of an Amarillo without Wonderland Park . Wonderland Park is the perfect amusement park.   It has roller coasters, a haunted mansion ride, children’s rides, water rides, arcades, and amusement park foods.   Families could come together. Their high school kids would run off to meet their friends to the Texas Tornado or the Big Splash Log Flume. Parents would take their toddlers to the merry-go-round or train.   Or if a family wanted to stay together, they could play a round of miniature golf.   For my generation, the annual visit to Wonderland Park was the highlight of the sum...

Day 2 Gratitude: a Sandstorm of Gratitude (IYKYK)

In my second day of gratitude, I would like to stick with showing gratitude towards some of my high school teachers.   I have once again not included names for privacy purposes.   I loved my time at Amarillo High School – attribution goes to my fellow students and the wonderful teachers.   In the interest of space and time, I will list out only a few that I am especially grateful for: 11 th Grade American History Teacher : History came to life through brilliant lessons and deep discussions / knowledge.   Success measured by all students being engaged, and many many students passing the AP American History exam.   If you know me, I love American History and can trace it back to this specific class. 11 th Grade English Teacher : This teacher taught multiple classes.   And all the students in those classes would read typically 25-50 pages each night for 9 months.   Vivid discussions, use of multi-media – in the 1990s no less.   Created portfoli...

Day 1 Gratitude: Thankful for the Three 'R's - Reading, [W]riting, and Running

I have seen multiple social media advertisements about taking a ‘gratitude journey’ in December.   In this, you journal / write something that you have much appreciation and thanks for in your life.   I am accepting this journey.   For me, I feel very blessed for the family and friends that I have.   I will focus on the later – the friends, acquaintances, colleagues; past and present; that are in my life*.   Each day, I will select someone different and write about them.   I will use a pseudonym for the person to protect individual identity.   If you read something and it sounds like you, it may very well be you. *** The first person is actually two people.   I honored them both during a ceremony 30 years ago as a high school senior.   It was two teachers who taught me fundamental lessons and shaped my life in ways that seemed unimaginable when I was in 6 th grade.** The first teacher was a gym coach who always pushed me to work hard. ...